A musical analysis of ‘Shallow’ from A Star Is Born (2024)

6 January 2019, 08:43 | Updated: 24 June 2019, 09:53

A musical analysis of ‘Shallow’ from A Star Is Born (1)

By Helena Asprou

It’s one of the biggest-selling songs of 2018 and has won a Golden Globe award, so let’s take a closer look at why this hit single has struck a chord

Directed by Bradley Cooper and starring pop icon Lady Gaga, A Star Is Born is a heartfelt tale of addiction and doomed love.

The movie tells the story of country singer Jackson Maine (played by Cooper) and struggling songwriter Ally (Gaga), who after a chance encounter quickly form a close bond.

Jackson propels Ally to fame and we’re led to feel hopeful for their future, but their relationship ends in tears as he struggles to fight his inner demons.

Since its release last October, the film and its original soundtrack have been topping charts all over the globe.

Sharing the same name as the movie, the soundtrack album includes the hit song 'Shallow' – a powerful pop ballad performed live on-set by Cooper and Gaga.

So, what is it about this moving melody that gives us all the feels?

A musical analysis of ‘Shallow’ from A Star Is Born (4)

Lady Gaga, Bradley Cooper - Shallow (A Star Is Born)

'Shallow' – a deeper meaning

This catchy song is the result of an epic collaboration between Bradley Cooper and Lady Gaga – but the duo’s creativity didn’t stop there.

Producer Mark Ronson, Dirty Pretty Things’ Antonio Rossomando, Miike Snow’s Andrew Wyatt and country music aficionado Lukas Nelson also contributed to the song’s success.

Speaking to Zane Lowe on Beats 1 Radio, Gaga explained the significance of 'Shallow': “We made this for Ally and Jack. It’s two people talking to each other about the need and the drive to dive into the deep end [of life and love] and stay away from the shallow area.”

Verse one – and that unmistakeable intro

Inspired by Eric Clapton, the intro to 'Shallow' is a mellow acoustic guitar riff, providing a stunning musical contrast against Gaga’s mighty vocals later on in the track.

Played at a gentle pace with frequent pauses and a time signature of 4/4, the song is relatively slow to start off with – mimicking the early stages of falling in love when a couple are still unsure of their feelings towards one another.

It lays the groundwork for Bradley Cooper’s raw vocal, which appears in the first verse and complements his lyrics perfectly: “Tell me somethin’ girl, are you happy in this modern world?”

Written in the key of G Major, the repeated rise and fall between notes G and E during: “Is there somethin’ else you’re searching for?” reflect Ally’s ongoing struggle to make it as a musician.

At this point in the movie, Cooper’s character Jackson questions Ally’s ambitions and encourages her to follow her dreams.

A musical analysis of ‘Shallow’ from A Star Is Born (5)

Now for the refrain

Next, we hear Jackson sing:

“I'm falling
In all the good times I find myself
Longin' for change
And in the bad times I fear myself”

Ironically, “I’m falling” is an ascending scale – but the lyric has a double meaning.

Although Jackson is beginning to fall in love with Ally, his hedonistic lifestyle will eventually be his downfall.

Find out more about all the nominees for Best Original Song at this year's Golden Globes >

Enter Lady Gaga…

For verse two, the main melody is repeated but the instrumentation changes – this time with added strings as a cello begins to play on the word ‘void’.

The use of vibrato and sustained notes are intended to add warmth as Ally sees through Jackson’s tough persona, while she asks him: “Ain’t it hard keeping it so hardcore?”

Then, the refrain reappears but with rich piano chords building texture as both the song and the characters' emotions evolve.

That ALMIGHTY chorus

This is where Gaga really gives it some gusto.

Sung forte (loud), the chorus is where we truly appreciate the meaning of this song:

‘I'm off the deep end, watch as I dive in
I'll never meet the ground
Crash through the surface, where they can't hurt us
We're far from the shallow now.’

Here, Ally compares falling in love to diving into water. The “deep” end offers hope and potential, whilst the “shallow” end symbolises trouble in her relationship with Jackson – an omen for the film’s heart-breaking ending.

The hard-hitting reality of the story is portrayed in the post-chorus, with repeated lyrics “In the shallow, shallow” sung by both characters, and a descending figure in the main melody reflecting the ebbs and flows of water (and of life).

The grand finale

As the song draws to a close, we hear bass drums kicking in with crashing cymbals to echo Ally’s powerful words: “Crash through the surface”.

This is especially poignant here as before she meets Jackson, Ally is rejected by the music industry over her looks – but now we are reminded that love and talent are more than just skin deep.

'Shallow' won 'Best Original Song' at the Golden Globes, which recognises outstanding achievements in film and took place on Sunday, 6 January at the Beverly Hilton hotel in Los Angeles.

A musical analysis of ‘Shallow’ from A Star Is Born (2024)

FAQs

What are the musical features of Shallow? ›

Composition and lyrical interpretation

A slow-burning rock, folk-pop and country power ballad, "Shallow" features mainly Nelson's acoustic guitar with Cooper and Gaga trading verses.

Can Bradley Cooper actually sing? ›

The actor does all the singing himself, and took six months of guitar and piano lessons to prepare for his role. Is Bradley Cooper really playing the guitar in A Star is Born? > Cooper's vocals are remarkably authentic. As an alcoholic and addict, Jackson Maine's vocals should tell a dark personal narrative.

What style of music is a star is born? ›

Often catchy and undeniably moving, the 70-minute soundtrack is a fusion of country, pop and blues rock, with heartfelt lyrics to match. Bradley Cooper, the film's leading composer, takes us on a journey through love, life struggles and the desire for change.

What is the theme of the star is born? ›

A key theme in 'A Star is Born' is how addiction destroys not only the lives of its victims but also the lives of their loved ones. There is a scene where Jackson apologizes to Ally for something he did while he was drunk. He is ashamed and knows he hurt and embarrassed her.

Why is Shallow so hard to sing? ›

“Shallow,” on the other hand, starts on that C5 and then just kind of hovers around it throughout. Sure, there are some G4's in it too, but there's a lot of A's, B's, C's, and even a D5 on a miserable “EE” vowel. It's tiring, and a lot of very capable singers close up part of the way through for lack of stamina.

What are the musical characteristics of the song? ›

What are the five characteristics of music? The five characteristics of music are sound (overtone, duration, amplitude, pitch, timbre), melody, rhythm, structure or form, expression, texture, and melody.

Is Lady Gaga really singing in A Star Is Born? ›

Recording Live Vocals

To pull this off, Ruder and the production sound team did a stage test at Warner Bros. to see if this was possible. They had a pre-recorded track of the band, which they played back on the stage. First, Cooper and Gaga did live vocals.

Who trained Bradley Cooper to sing? ›

Star Is Born' with Howard Stern.

Did Bradley Cooper really play the guitar in A Star Is Born? ›

However, in one of his interviews, Cooper revealed that indeed it wasn't him playing in the film. Although he sang and recorded all the songs live (and did it well), the guitars were played by Lukas Nelson (the son of Willie Nelson).

Did Lady Gaga write all the music for A Star Is Born? ›

Out of 18 original tracks on the soundtrack, Lady Gaga is credited as a writer or cowriter on 13 of them, including the powerful finale "I'll Never Love Again." The big ballad featured in the trailers, "Shallow," is one of her signature songs, co-written with Mark Ronson, Anthony Rossomando, and Andrew Wyatt.

Who is singing "Pretty Woman in A Star Is Born"? ›

Hammered to the point of being barely conscious, he nevertheless makes it through some rowdy guitar licks on a rousing cover of Orbison's famous “Oh, Pretty Woman,” while the real-life Brandi Carlile takes the vocal lead. It's an exciting, memorable scene.

Is A Star Is Born based on a real story? ›

A Star Is Born isn't based on a true story, but might as well be. As the Oscars approach, so do more reminders of this as women come forward with their experiences with allegedly psychologically abusive musicians.

Why does Jackson hang himself in A Star Is Born? ›

Through all four major versions of A Star Is Born, the basic arc leading to the tragic death of the male lead remains the same. Cooper's adaptation had his character Jackson Maine hang himself in the garage of his home after realizing that his alcoholism and addiction were burdens on his wife Ally (Lady Gaga).

What did Kris Kristofferson say about a star is born? ›

Kris Kristofferson said, "Filming with Barbra Streisand is an experience which may have cured me of the movies."

What did Barbara Streisand say about a star is born? ›

“So, I was surprised when I saw how alike it was to the version that I did in 1976.” Streisand went on to say that she “thought it was the wrong idea” for the remake but that she “can't argue with success” after it grossed $436m (£315m) at the box office.

What are the key features of a musical? ›

Musical theatre is a theatrical performance that includes four major elements: songs, spoken dialogue, acting, and dance.

What does the musical play features? ›

Musical theatre, also known as a musical, is a show combining songs, spoken dialogue, acting and dancing. Musicals usually tell a story covering a range of emotions, from humour and love to anger and sadness.

What are the key musical features of jazz? ›

A few defining characteristics of jazz music include the use of improvisation, syncopation, irregular beats, solos, and call and response techniques.

What are the key features of concept musicals? ›

Concept musicals are shows in which the overall theme or message is more important than the story itself. The purpose of the show is not so much to tell the story but more to leave the audience with food for thought. Examples include A Chorus Line and Chicago.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Roderick King

Last Updated:

Views: 5247

Rating: 4 / 5 (51 voted)

Reviews: 90% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Roderick King

Birthday: 1997-10-09

Address: 3782 Madge Knoll, East Dudley, MA 63913

Phone: +2521695290067

Job: Customer Sales Coordinator

Hobby: Gunsmithing, Embroidery, Parkour, Kitesurfing, Rock climbing, Sand art, Beekeeping

Introduction: My name is Roderick King, I am a cute, splendid, excited, perfect, gentle, funny, vivacious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.